Being a Good Ally: Lessons Learned at a UC Davis GDOPx Workshop

Yesterday, I attended UCD’s Graduate Diversity Orientation Program (Extension)’s (GDOPx) workshop on being a good ally led by Dr. Jinni Pradhan. I thought it would be nice to take the time here go over a few takeaways on basic allyship as well as some new perspectives about allyship I hadn’t considered before.

What is allyship? The Anti-Oppression Network has a great article that defines allyship as “an active, consistent, and arduous practice of unlearning and re-evaluating, in which a person of privilege seeks to operate in solidarity with a marginalized group of people.”  In its most basic form, allyship involves developing and practicing empathy towards all people. This includes everything from using inclusive language (using preferred or neutral pronouns, or “folks” instead of “guys”) and avoiding making assumptions about other people or groups of people, to shutting down racist great-aunts at Thanksgiving dinners, to self-educating on topics rather than asking marginalized groups to educate you, to actively attending rallies protesting oppressive policy.

One of the first steps towards becoming a good ally (or an ally, period) is recognizing your privilege. What is privilege? Everyday Feminisim has a good article covering the basics, and defines privilege as a set of unearned benefits given to people who fit into a specific social group.

The workshop emphasized that everyone has a different set of privileges because everyone has had a different lived experience.

Allyship also involves working towards intersectional liberation of people belonging to oppressed groups. Here’s a wonderful comic created by Miriam Dobson (twitter) illustrating intersectionality better than I could explain it:

Intersectionality
Comic licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License by Miriam Dobson.

Allyship is work, and involves making mistakes, recognizing and apologizing for those mistakes, and moving on. At the workshop, we discussed calling in rather than out when others make mistakes: for example, if a person says something that could be construed as ableist during a dinner party, taking that person aside and explaining one-on-one to them in a respectful manner why their comment may be harmful or exclusionary is better than calling them out in front of the other party guests – bringing them into the conversation and learning process rather than making them feel left out.

We also watched this great video from Franchesca Ramsey (host of MTV’s Decoded; twitter, facebook, website) outlining tips for being an ally:

The most important takeaway from this video is that ally is a VERB, which implies action: the work towards being a better ally is never over. One can always improve.

Some other things that allyship can involve:

  • being uncomfortable, and being ok with that discomfort
  •  active listening
  • the Golden rule AND the Platinum rule: Treat others the way THEY want to be treated
  • being aware of current events that affect marginalized communities
  • recognizing that intention is not the same as impact: even if someone means well, their words or actions may have a negative impact, and that means something despite all good intentions

There were two points that I came away with from the workshop that I’ve never really thought about before, and want to emphasize here:

  1. Allyship is a give and take; a partnership. Allies who are not members of a specific marginalized community often receive more praise and are more valued than allies from that marginalized community. What folks should recognize is that being exposed to diverse viewpoints, experiences, and cultures is a privilege: diversity makes our communities richer and betters our understanding of the world. Allies on both sides of the partnership benefit from participating in and leveraging the alliance.
  2. I’ve heard a lot of people react defensively when their flaws as an ally are pointed out. I think this comes from the assumption that allyship is synonymous with basic human decency. In reality, it’s more nuanced than this: instead, we should assume that all people start from a place of poor allyship with groups of people they don’t share qualities with, and the farther removed from a group you’ve been all your life, the worse ally you’re naturally going to be. If a person has never had lived experiences as a member of a marginalized group, how could they ever be an effective ally for members of that group? People are not just born knowing what it’s like to be someone else: that’s why the phrase “walking in someone else’s shoes” exists – we were all wearing our own pairs of shoes before we tried another’s on.

I think it’s best to think of one’s self as an “ally in training” for all perpetuity because we can always improve, and self-improvement is a task that is never completed. I am just at the beginning of this learning process, much of which has involved consuming as much self-education materials as I can get my hands on, and stepping aside to really listen to people carefully and thoughtfully without taking up space myself. I think this has been an easier way to approach allyship because I’m not taking many risks in which I may make mistakes. This blog post in itself represents a next step for me: I am speaking out, a little – but hopefully also magnifying others’ voices and reaching people who may not have been exposed to these ideas before. I hope I’m not speaking over anyone else.

I encourage anyone who is reading this to do the research on all these topics themselves. There is so much more to this than I can ever write in a blog post, and this is really the farthest thing from my area of expertise. I wrote this to expose some folks in my social circles to these ideas, many of which they may not come across otherwise. Please feel free to engage with me one-on-one if you are interested in learning more about these topics, or if you have any concerns about any of the ideas I’ve put forth here. I’m happy to amend my statements if they are problematic or oversimplified.

The feature image is actually just a snapshot of the interactive word cloud found here.

See upcoming Equity and Inclusion events at UC Davis here.
For more on Diversity Resources on UC Davis’ campus, click here.

Advertisements

New study: Individual actions against climate change DO matter!

A new study investigated the impacts of individual actions against climate change, and found that what we do in our everyday lives can actually make a difference! The accompanying graphic has made the rounds, and the media and public alike have focused on the fact that having one fewer child will have the greatest impact (is this really a surprising find??), but there’s a lot more to take away from the study that has largely been ignored in the public eye, and Grist has a nice news brief that sums it up well, writing: “the researchers found that behavioral shifts could be faster than waiting for national climate policies and widespread energy transformations. As far as I know, this is the very first comprehensive analysis on the effectiveness of specific individual climate actions.”  Read the original article and check out the graphic here.

 

Featured image of the Earth By NASA [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons.

Pollinator Week Activities at USDA Headquarters! -Washington, D.C.

Below is an announcement from a listserv I subscribe to about activities going on in D.C. tomorrow in honor of National Pollinator Week! If you’re in the area, check it out!

It’s National Pollinator Week! Bee with us tomorrow (Rain or Shine!) for a fun-filled day to celebrate the hardest working friends of farmers and consumers at the eighth annual Pollinator Week Festival on Friday, June 23 from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. outside USDA Headquarters in Washington, D.C.!

Special highlights include:

  • See live bats from around the world, including local insect-eating bats, leaf-nosed bats from South America and giant flying fox bats from Africa and Asia. Learn how bats are very important to ecosystems by eating pesky insects and spreading seeds or pollinating flowers of plants like mango, banana and pineapple.
  • Meet beekeepers from USDA-ARS Bee Research Laboratory and watch honey bees at work in an observation hive. Learn about pollinated foods like raspberries and taste honey from local hives including the People’s Garden Apiary, US National Arboretum, DC Water, and Bee Research Lab at VegU in the USDA Farmers Market.
  • Explore the People’s Garden to collect and identify insectsTake home pollinator-friendly plants like milkweed, oregano or bee balm to plant for pollinators.
  • Enjoy Free Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream! Honey bees pollinate many of the ingredients used to make ice creams and sorbets. To spread their love for honey bees Nestlé Dreyer’s Ice Cream is donating free cups of Strawberry Ice Cream and Pineapple Coconut Ice Cream – both bee-dependent flavors – to festival and bat walk attendees. Supplies are limited.
  • Shop the USDA Farmers Market during the day (9 a.m. – 2 p.m.) and in the evening (4 p.m. – 8 p.m.). Signs will highlight which food we’d be without if not for the hard work of honey bees, birds, butterflies, bats and other pollinators.
  • Walk with Bats! Meet at 8 p.m. at the corner of 12th Street and Jefferson Drive, SW in Washington, D.C. to attend a special “bat walk”! The walk discusses local DC bats, how they navigate the night skies, avoid predators and catch insects. Also, test out electronic bat detectors that pick up the ultrasonic calls that bats emit to navigate the darkness.

Exhibitors include:

USDA Agencies and Initiatives

Agricultural Marketing Service

Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

Beltsville Agricultural Research Center Bee Research Laboratory

Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion

Farm Service Agency

Natural Resources Conservation Service

The People’s Garden

U.S. Forest Service

 

Other Federal and State Departments

DC Water

Department of Energy and the Environment

Smithsonian Natural Museum of Natural History

United States Environmental Protection Agency

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

 

Partners

Million Pollinator Garden Challenge

National Honey Board

National Wildlife Federation

Organization for Bat Conservation

Pollinator Partnership

University of Maryland Extension

 

The Pollinator Festival is free, fun and educational for both youth and adults. For more information follow @PeoplesGarden on Twitter. Sign language interpreters will be present all day in the yellow information tent in the USDA Farmers Market.

Featured image of Hylaeus bee taken by:
By Orangeaurochs from Sandy, Bedfordshire, United Kingdom – Solitary bee (Hylaeus?), Sandy, Bedfordshire, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=48913743

Fun facts about native bees for National Pollinator Month!

Pollinators (read: native bees) hold a place near and dear to my heart. I’ve also had the great fortune of being able to study them in the wild, learning about their wondrous ways and marveling at their impressive diversity. I’m excited that June is National Pollinator Month because it gives me an excuse to write about everything bees! Let’s kick it off with a listicle to wet your appetite for more bee reads to come. But before I start, here’s the introductory paragraph to the US Forest Service’s handy guide to native bees that nicely sums up the theme for this month’s blog posts:

“Native bees are a hidden treasure. From alpine meadows in the national forests of the Rocky Mountains to the Sonoran Desert in the Coronado National Forest in Arizona and from the boreal forests of the Tongass National Forest in Alaska to the Ocala National Forest in Florida, bees can be found anywhere in North America, where flowers bloom. From forests to farms, from cities to wildlands, there are 4,000 native bee species in the United States, from the tiny Perdita minima to large carpenter bees. Most people do not realize that there were no honey bees in America before European settlers brought hives from Europe. These resourceful animals promptly managed to escape from domestication. As they had done for millennia in Europe and Asia, honey bees formed swarms and set up nests in hollow trees. Native pollinators, especially bees other than honey bees, have been pollinating the continent’s flowering plants since long before the arrival of honey bees. Even in today’s vastly altered landscapes, they continue to do the yeomen’s share of pollination, especially when it comes to native plants. The honey bee, remarkable as it is, does not know how to pollinate tomato or eggplant flowers. It does very poorly compared to native bees when pollinating many native plants, such as pumpkins, cherries, blueberries, and cranberries. Let us take a closer look at this forgotten treasure of native bees.”

Fun facts about native bees:

  1. There are 4000 species of native bees in America! Just to re-emphasize what the US Forest Service says above, because this is SO important, honey bees are non-native to the US, and before there were honey bees, crops, trees, and wildflowers were all pollinated by native bees. Native bees evolved to pollinate their local native plants, so it makes sense that they would be the best, most natural candidates for pollinating those same native plants now. Honey bees are definitely more effective at pollinating certain crops, but our collective dependence on honey bees for pollination has gotten us into trouble – honey bees aren’t doing so well, as you might have heard. Part of this is because domestication isn’t all that healthy for them, especially when used in large-scale farming operations. Honey bees also tend to outcompete native bees and therefore harm native communities, so sometimes they can do more bad than good. I’m simplifying all of this because this is a listicle, but the research is accurately reported in many sources – check them out with a google search on “native bees and honey bees” if you’re interested, just make sure the sources you read are citing scientific articles published in peer-reviewed journals.

  2. Some bees mimic wasps, and some flies mimic wasps and bees.

    Both of these are flies! Left: a bee mimic, right: a wasp mimic. This is a super cool adaptation meant to deter predators. It also makes it difficult to differentiate between wasps, flies, and bees when they’re flying around outside. As a field tech, I eventually became adept at this skill and can pretty easily ID the insect family on the fly, but this was my full-time job and it took a lot of practice. If you’re interested in learning the specific characteristics that differ between these insects, here’s a good place to start: https://beespotter.org/topics/mimics/


  3. Native bees are often very small and go by unnoticed, but you can observe them almost anywhere if you are patient.
    They can often be as small as an ant, so keep your eyes peeled or use a magnifying hand lens. If you sit in front of a clump of flowers in the summer between 10 am and 2 pm when it is sunny, there is no wind, and the temperature is above 70 degrees, you’ll probably see some native bees within 15 minutes. If you don’t, you’re likely choosing the wrong clump of flowers. Unless you strategically plant your garden, your best bet is to go searching in a natural prairie or forested area. Remember that these are native bees, and so may be less likely to visit the types of exotic flowers often sold by nurseries and landscapers.

    There are many different types of native bees, but here are some of the more common groups:


    Metallic_Green_Bee_-_Agapostemon_species,_Meadowood_Farm_SRMA,_Mason_Neck,_Virginia
    Agapostemon are my favorite kind of native bee, with some species sporting characteristic yellow and black stripes on the abdomen, and some completely metallic green or blue.


    cf Augochlora pura F
    Augochlora
    are beautiful metallic green/blue bees that can look similar to Agapostemon.


    Colletes_-_Flickr_-_S._Rae_(1)
    Colletes are more “classic” looking bees, with yellow and black stripes and plenty of fuzz.




    Hylaeus
    are quite small, with a mostly black body often featuring yellow markings around the face, legs, and upper thorax. For scale, the tiny black speck on the flower petal in the left-hand image is a Hylaeus bee!


    Andrena are another group of mostly black and hairy bees:

    Andrena_sp_01


    By now, some of the species are starting to look pretty similar. If you’re interested in actually learning specimen ID, there’s a wonderful, specific guide that takes you through identifying characteristics one by one http://www.discoverlife.org/mp/20q. This is really fun, but requires a microscope; bees that have been caught, preserved, and properly curated; and plenty of pre-identified museum specimens with which to compare your specimen. But with a little training, motivation, and the internet at your disposal, anyone can do it! One caveat: I am sure most people could easily learn to identify bees to genus, but when it comes to species IDs, for some speciose, cryptic, or rare genuses like Lasioglossum and Hylaeus, you really need an expert taxonomist to verify the ID. I always encourage citizen science, so if you’re interested in this kind of thing, contact me and I can get you in touch with the right people!


    A few more genuses include Nomada, Anthidium, Megachile, Bombus, and Osmia.

    This slideshow requires JavaScript.


    A quick caveat: not all bee species that you can observe in the wild from these groups are native, but the vast majority are. There are about 20 non-native bee species in America, including species of MegachileHylaeus, Chelostoma, Hoplitis, Anthidium, and Andrena. Learn a bit about these species here:
    https://pollinator.cals.cornell.edu/wild-bees-new-york/introduced-nonnative-bees.


  4. Bees are descended from wasps, but while wasps are carnivores and sometimes even cannibals, bees are herbivores.Bees actually eat both nectar and pollen! Adults mostly eat nectar, but pollen is also stored as food for larvae. Perhaps intuitively, nectar supplies bees with high energy needs, and pollen provides more protein.

  5. Some bees are generalists, while others specialize on certain flower species.Bumblebees often pollinate all different flowers, while some groups of bees specialize on certain flower groups or species. Squash bees pollinate cucurbit plants like zucchini, pumpkin, or squash. Macropis bees only forage on loosestrife, and Anthemurgus passiflorae is a highly specialized bee that only visits flowers of the species yellow passionflower, Passiflora lutea. Some of this is based on the bee shape and size “matching” with flower shape and size- only long-tongued bees and tiny bees can access nectar at the bottoms of long, narrow flowers, while almost all bees can reap the nectar and pollen rewards of sunflowers and other asters.

  6. Different bee species display varying amounts of sociality.

    Everyone knows the honey bee is super social and lives in colonies with rigid caste systems, cooperation, and even dances to communicate with each other. However, many of the native bees listed above live in varying states of solitude. Some live together at certain life stages, some create nests and leave the offspring to fend for themselves, and some, like bumblebees, still live in colonies but don’t reach the level of sociality that honey bees do.


  7. Miners, leaf-cutters, masons, carpenters: different bees have different nesting habitats.

    Mining bees dig holes in the ground and live in them. Species from Andrena and Colletes are miner bees. Osmia are carpenter bees that carve out nests in dead wood, and Megachile are mason bees that nest in holes and leaf cutters that use pieces of leaves to line their nests.


  8. Some bees are nectar “robbers.” 

    Remember what I said about longue-tongued bees tending to drink nectar from long-tubed flowers, and short-tongued bees foraging on smaller flowers? Well, it would be nice for science if nature complied with these seemingly obvious rules, but as is usually the case, nature is more complex than that! Some bees have learned to “cheat” the system by poking holes in the bottoms of nectar tubes and drinking nectar by using their tongue as a straw. From an evolutionary perspective, this behavior “cheats” the system: the bee gets all the benefit without helping the plant out by pollinating it. Usually, pollination is classified as a “mutualism,” where two partners get mutual benefit from interacting, but in this case, the plant misses out.



If you found this interesting, look out for future posts in which I’ll be writing about topics such as attracting native bees to your yard, native bees’ role in agricultural crop pollination, the science on the effects of pesticides on bees, and native bee conservation. The US Forest Service’s native bee guide also provides more detail on many of the topics discussed here. The Xerces Society also plays a prominent role in pollinator protection – for an excellent resource on all things pollinators, visit their website here.

Happy Pollinator Month! 🙂



Related articles

To learn more about my research on bees, see this article in a New Jersey Watershed Association newsletter: https://www.raritanheadwaters.org/2015/10/29/the-buzz-on-bee-research-at-fairview-farm/

If you think insects are really cool and you want to learn more about how they live their lives, check out this fun piece about insect communication that you can find here: https://esuglia.wordpress.com/2015/10/02/insect-communication-its-an-art/

More bee & insect articles by yours truly!

Bees:
https://thisisnoordinaryworld.wordpress.com/2014/04/02/a-bees-buzz/

https://esuglia.wordpress.com/2017/05/16/paper-of-the-day-pyke-et-al-2016-effects-of-climate-change-on-phenologies-and-distributions-of-bumble-bees-and-the-plants-they-visit/

Insects:
https://issuu.com/catalyst_magazine/docs/catalyst_fall_2014

https://amisstome.wordpress.com/2013/04/23/now-you-see-me-now-you-dont-insect-mimicry-and-crypticity/

Photograph credit

Bee mimic: By USGS Bee Inventory and Monitoring Lab from Beltsville, USA – Asilidae, U, Side, Carroll Co., MD_2013-07-23-15.07.52 ZS PMax. Uploaded by Jacopo Werther, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=28757280

Wasp mimic: By Bruce Marlin [CC BY-SA 2.5 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5)%5D, via Wikimedia Commons

Agapostemon bee: By Judy Gallagher [CC BY 2.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0)%5D, via Wikimedia Commons

Augochlora bee: By maxson.erin – cf Augochlora pura F, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=44336582

Colletes bee: By S. Rae from Scotland, UK – Colletes, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=50700247

Hylaeus bee images, in clockwise order from left to right:

By Orangeaurochs from Sandy, Bedfordshire, United Kingdom – Solitary bee (Hylaeus?), Sandy, Bedfordshire, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=48913744
By Orangeaurochs from Sandy, Bedfordshire, United Kingdom – Solitary bee (Hylaeus?), Sandy, Bedfordshire, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=48913743
By Katja Schulz from Washington, D. C., USA – Yellow-faced Bee, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=40573628

Andrena bees: By ©entomart, Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=867032

Osmia bee: By Judy Gallagher – http://www.flickr.com/photos/52450054@N04/9047304581/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=54772670

Bombus bee: By H.Kohori – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=26831732

Megachile bee: By maxson.erin – Megachile rotundata F, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=50989578

Anthidium bee: By Juan Emilio from Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, España – Anthidium palliventre??, CC BY-SA 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=24985755

Nomada bee: By Judy Gallagher – http://www.flickr.com/photos/52450054@N04/26307754972/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=54772930

Pollinators in Urban Landscapes: Event in DC

Anyone in Washington DC? If so, head over to the National Museum of Natural History to learn about pollinators in urban landscapes!

http://go.si.edu/site/Calendar?view=Detail&id=101821&s_srcr=part_em_gk_er_text

Fun fact: there are LOTS of native bee species in urban areas!! Preliminary results of a study that hasn’t been published yet compared rare bee diversity in agricultural, urban, and forested settings – and interestingly, urban settings won out a good portion of the time! Why? We’ll have to wait and find out when her publications come out. But an initial hypothesis of mine is that urban landscapes offer lots of structural complexity where bees can create nests, and that people plant lots of diverse flowers in their window boxes, gardens, and landscaped areas.

#bees#pollinatormonth

Description of the event from the website:

“The Buzz About Urban Pollinators

Join moderator Timothy Beatley, professor at the University of Virginia and founder of the Biophilic Cities Network, Gary Krupnick, conservation biologist at the National Museum of Natural History, Catherine Werner, sustainability director for the City of St. Louis, and other experts for a discussion about projects that are benefiting both people and pollinators in urban environments.

Learn about successful projects such as St. Louis’s “Milkweed for Monarchs” initiative, as well as Smithsonian research, including the National Museum of Natural History’s Pollinator Garden. Participants will discuss government and grassroots recommendations for sustaining healthy pollinator populations.”

 

Feature image is the same one on the event web page and was taken by Katja Shulz, Smithsonian.

Scientists refute Scott Pruitt’s erroneous climate warming “leveling off” claims in Nature paper

In a somewhat unprecedented move, Benjamin Santer and colleagues have published a paper reiterating the scientific consensus regarding tropospheric warming over the past two decades in order to refute recent claims by EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt that warming has “leveled off.” Read the article here:

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-02520-7